File photo
Fleetowner 35393 Dump Truck Insurance
Fleetowner 35393 Dump Truck Insurance
Fleetowner 35393 Dump Truck Insurance
Fleetowner 35393 Dump Truck Insurance
Fleetowner 35393 Dump Truck Insurance

Intrastate vs. interstate: Type of shipment key in liability case

Nov. 30, 2018
Attorneys recommended that fleets not overlook even the smallest detail when selecting insurance coverage and writing contracts.

An insurance company was recently found not liable for damages because the truck blamed for causing an accident was actively involved in intrastate shipping, and not listed under the policy in question.

The decision in the case, Lyles v. FTL, was written Thomas E. Johnston, chief judge at the United States District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia.

According to court documents, Patricia Lyles was stopped at a red light on U.S. 119 in November 2014 when a loaded dump truck collided with her vehicle.

The truck was owned by K&K Trucking, but leased to FTL Inc. It was hauling materials from a building demolition site in Chapmanville, WV, to a landfill in Charleston, WV.

The rear-end collision forced Lyles’ vehicle off the road, causing permanent physical and psychological injuries, according to her lawsuit.

As part of an initial settlement, insurance firm National Casualty Company paid Lyles about $945,000 on behalf of K&K. The agreement allowed her to seek additional compensation from FTL.

Both K&K and FTL had insurance policies with National Casualty, along with the federally required MCS-90 endorsement.

K&K’s agreement with FTL stated it would obtain $1 million of liability coverage, and name FTL as an additional insured on the policy. However, the dump truck in the accident was not listed as a covered vehicle on FTL’s policy, leading National Casualty to deny further coverage.

National Casualty contended there was no liability under the MCS-90 endorsement because the dump truck was engaged in an intrastate trip at the time of the accident.

The judge agreed, stating “the fact that the trucking agreement between FTL and K&K contemplates occasional interstate transportation of property does not alter the nature of the accident at issue, which occurred during an intrastate shipment.”

Had this been an interstate shipment, FTL could potentially have been also been responsible for damages. The MCS-90 endorsement is required to provide all sides additional protection when using rented trucks, borrowed trailers, and any equipment not specifically covered under an insurance policy.

During a recent webinar, attorneys with Fox Rothschild LLP suggested that nuanced cases such as this one are becoming more commonplace across the country as more companies turn to independent contractors for at least some work.

Attorneys Fredric Marcinak and Rob Green recommended that fleets not overlook even the smallest detail when selecting insurance coverage and writing contracts.

They noted it is also important to stay on top of recent legal decisions across the country, which can be used to help guide strategies when litigation may arise. In this particular case, it could affect other pending cases in other jurisdictions involving intrastate trucking disputes.

About the Author

Neil Abt

Neil Abt, editorial director at Fleet Owner, is a veteran journalist with over 20 years of reporting experience, including 15 years spent covering the trucking industry. A graduate of American University in Washington, D.C., he began his career covering sports for The Washington Post newspaper, followed by a position in the newsroom of America Online (AOL) and then both reporting and leadership roles at Transport Topics. Abt is based out of Portland, Oregon.

Sponsored Recommendations

Tackling the Tech Shortage: Lessons in Recruiting Talent and Reducing Turnover

Discover innovative strategies for recruiting and retaining tech talent in the trucking industry at our April 16th webinar, where experts will share insights on competitive pay...

Stop Sweating Temperature Excursions

Advanced chemical indicators give you the peace of mind that comes from reliable insights into your supply chains. Compromised shipments can be identified the moment they arrive...

Stop Sweating Temperature Excursions

Advanced chemical indicators give you the peace of mind that comes from reliable insights into your supply chains. Compromised shipments can be identified the moment they arrive...

How Electric Vehicles Help You Prolong the Life of Your Fleet

Before adopting electric vehicles for commercial/government fleets, prioritize cost inquiries. Maintenance is essential; understand the upkeep of EV fleets. Here’s what you need...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of FleetOwner, create an account today!