• New Oil, New Cost Analysis

    As the new CI-4 PLUS oil gets ready to be introduced Sept. 1, it’s most likely going to cost more than its CI-4 predecessor
    Aug. 30, 2004
    2 min read

    As the new CI-4 PLUS oil gets ready to be introduced Sept. 1, it’s most likely going to cost more than its CI-4 predecessor. But Reginald Dias, director of commercial products for ConocoPhillips Lubricants, said choosing a particular oil formulation solely on price isn’t always the best way to go.

    “The cost vs. benefits evaluation cannot be made strictly on the purchase price alone,” he told Fleet Owner, in terms of selecting CI-4 Plus vs. CI-4. “For an operator, the total lubrication cost includes the purchase price and the life-cycle cost: the cost or benefits of maintenance and down time.”

    Introduced in December 2001 for the new low-emission diesel engines brought to market in October 2002, CI-4 proved to be very good at handling the higher heat and soot loads generated by most of the low-emission engines on the market.

    However, lubricant makers and engine OEMs found that in some cases the soot being generated by cooled EGR was much higher than expected. In addition, it was almost a different kind of soot, one that thickened the oil much more rapidly, so the oil formulation had to be altered. This led to the creation of CI-4 Plus.

    Dias added that getting more capability out of a particular grade of oil – in terms of longer oil drain intervals, for example – can more than offset the higher initial purchase price.

    “CI-4 Plus oil provides added protection and performance benefits not afforded by the previous generation oils,” he said. “Though the cost and benefits may not be specific or will vary depending on the equipment and type of service, [higher] pricing is often offset by the added value that comes with a higher performance product. Cost offsets may result via reduced maintenance, reduced down time, extended drain capability, reduced wear and improved engine durability.”

    About the Author

    Sean Kilcarr

    Editor in Chief

    Sean Kilcarr is a former longtime FleetOwner senior editor who wrote for the publication from 2000 to 2018. He served as editor-in-chief from 2017 to 2018.

     

    Voice your opinion!

    To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of FleetOwner, create an account today!

    Sign up for our free eNewsletters

    Latest from News

    ID 119046131 © Jonathan Weiss | Dreamstime.com
    English language proficiency support
    A FleetOwner survey illustrates how industry readers view the government renewed English language proficiency enforcement. Respondents overwhelmingly support ELP in out-of-service...
    Daimler Truck
    Daimler and Volvo's Coretura leadership
    Two of the largest global truck OEMs have established a joint venture to develop one software-defined vehicle platform, bringing standardization to the industry. While the company...
    Nissan
    Lofaro succeeds Judy Wheeler, who is retiring after nearly 15 years of dedicated service to the brand.
    Major leadership changes are happening for Mack Trucks, Volvo Trucks North America, and Nissan Americas.