• Supreme Court declines to hear case on California emissions waiver

    The U.S. Supreme Court declined to review a lawsuit by 17 states that argued California’s vehicle emissions waiver was unconstitutional. The decision is another legal victory for the waiver, which faced several major legal challenges in the last two years.
    Dec. 17, 2024
    2 min read
    ID 103695803 © Pattanaphong Khuankaew | Dreamstime.com
    court ruling gavel

    California’s vehicle emissions waiver survived another legal challenge after the Supreme Court declined to review a lawsuit against the waiver’s constitutionality.

    The legal challenge was filed by 17 states against EPA in 2022, arguing that EPA’s California emissions waiver was unconstitutional. An appeals court unanimously rejected the states’ challenge, and the Supreme Court refused to review the matter.

    California is the only U.S. state allowed to set its own vehicle emissions regulations under the Clean Air Act. EPA grants California its emissions autonomy through waivers.

    These waivers often receive legal challenges. According to the climate change litigation database by Columbia Law School, over seven lawsuits targeted California’s emissions regulations since its reinstatement in 2022.

    The plaintiffs targeting California’s standards include major trucking industry groups: the Western States Trucking Association, the California Trucking Association, the Nebraska Trucking Association, and the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association all participated in legal battles against the waiver since 2022.

    History of the states’ lawsuit

    The lawsuit is part of a yearslong partisan back-and-forth on California’s Clean Air Act waiver.

    In 2019, the Trump administration revoked California’s Clean Air Act waiver. The Biden administration reversed the move in March 2022 when EPA reinstated the California waiver.

    See also: Fleets Explained: Emissions regulations

    By May 2022, a group of 17 states’ Republican attorneys general filed a lawsuit against EPA requesting that the Court of Appeals block the waiver. The states claimed that the emissions waiver violated the state sovereignty clause implied by the Constitution.

    In April, the U.S. Court of Appeals rejected the states’ challenge, disagreeing with their constitutional argument and additionally finding that the states did not have standing.

    The states asked the Supreme Court to review the decision. The Supreme Court declined to take on the case.

    About the Author

    Jeremy Wolfe

    Editor

    Editor Jeremy Wolfe joined the FleetOwner team in February 2024. He graduated from the University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point with majors in English and Philosophy. He previously served as Editor for Endeavor Business Media's Water Group publications.

    Voice your opinion!

    To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of FleetOwner, create an account today!

    Sign up for our free eNewsletters

    Latest from News

    Patton Logistics Group
    Patton Logistics Group includes Watsontown Trucking (No. 248 on the FleetOwner 500: For-Hire list), Patton Warehousing, and Patton Logistics.
    FleetOwner 500 for-hire carrier adds dozens of trucks, hundreds of trailers, maintenance facilities, and much more warehousing real estate and potential for its Patton Logistics...
    ID 186175420 © Noipornpan | Dreamstime.com
    medical examination
    A new rule implemented by FMCSA will require that driver medical exam results be submitted electronically and within a calendar day of the examination.
    Josh Fisher | FleetOwner
    On-highway diesel pump prices sat at $3.775 per gallon, up from June 16’s $3.571 average. While it didn’t see the same price hike, average U.S. gasoline prices also increased by more than 7 cents this week, according to EIA, which tracked the fuel at $3.213.
    Middle East conflict helps fuel pump price surges nationwide. Gas is up to $3.213 per gallon; diesel is $3.775, but analyst doesn’t expect ‘apocalyptic spikes’ to continue.