Photo: Vitpho/Dreamstime
Trcker Walking Cowboy Hat Vitpho Dreamstime

As recovery looms, trucking faces driver supply dilemma

Oct. 12, 2020
Fleet recruiting experts discuss the challenges of finding drivers as the economy improves and how to solve them.

Many signs in the trucking industry are pointing to strong demand for freight as 2020 ends and 2021 begins, though individual fleets are grappling with a multitude of factors, making it more difficult to find drivers to move that freight. The for-hire segment’s driver supply is dwindling due to the retirement of veteran truckers, drivers’ ability to pass drug tests, and competition from other “blue-collar” industries such as manufacturing and construction, as well as local delivery and private fleets.

At the same time, the economy is preparing to awaken from the long slumber it’s been in since COVID-19 hit. FTR Transportation Intelligence projected utilization will accelerate in Q1 of 2021, pushing freight rates higher than the 10-year average by the next summer. That would be on par with 2018 numbers.

The National Transportation Institute is hearing that a major recovery could start this fall. In this regard, Q4 is going to have a 2018 feel, “but with complications,” said NTI CEO Leah Shaver

“Most fleets report that they could do four times the amount of work that they are doing, if only they had qualified drivers,” Shaver said during a recent FleetOwner webinar sponsored by Salesforce on driver retention and recruitment.

Because of the pandemic, training schools and the Department of Motor Vehicles installations have reduced capacity or closed—with some schools dropping by 40%, limiting the amount of newly certified drivers available. Furthermore, 71% of fleets halted training programs, according to an NTI survey. Altogether, Shaver said the new pool of drivers could be reduced by 30 to 40%.

Now there is a mad dash to find qualified drivers.

“After stalling the recruiting pipeline for at least Q2 and even part of Q3, most [fleets] are reporting extreme challenges and increases in cost as they rebuild their pipeline,” Shaver said.

Some of those extreme challenges in long-haul trucking are all part of the job, Shaver, a former driver recruiter and fleet director of human resources, explained. “Driving is overall considered undesirable. It has long days, is physically demanding, there’s heavy oversight and an independent demographic,” she said.

Private fleets and local delivery jobs negate some of these hardships.

“The wages tend not to be as much, but you get more home time, obviously, and also you have a lot less federal regulation to worry about,” said Avery Vise, FTR vice president of trucking, on local delivery.

Other industries are also siphoning off potential talent by offering equal or better pay with a better work-life balance. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, heavy and tractor-trailer drivers' median pay is $45,260. By contrast, a machinist median wage in 2019 was $45,750. That requires up to two years of training, done on-the-job, and/or through vocational schools and community colleges, but the job is more predictable and there are no long periods away from home.

Making matters worse, the generation gap has created a situation where the drivers who love what they do simply can’t rack up miles like they used to, the spirit willing but the body always isn’t. Retirement accounts for 54% of the driver shortage, NTI said. And when Baby Boomers retire, the smaller Generation X pool is not a large enough source from which to draw.

“The average age in the pool of fleets that we survey is 54 years old, the average age of new entrants is 38 years old, and new entrants do not make up for add for exits,” Shaver said. “Millennials are really at the early stages of entering the industry.”

Then there’s the challenge of finding drivers who can pass a drug test. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s Drug & Alcohol Clearinghouse, which tracks those who have tested positive and if and when they can return to duty, identified 29,000 drivers who failed drug tests or refused to take them from late 2019 to July. Shaver noted that due to the strict rules and fleets now hair testing, potential candidates are “self-selecting” and leaving the industry.

What to do?

The most obvious answer has been to increase pay. In 2018, NTI found driver pay increased by 10% to make up for the under 4% unemployment and increased driver demand.

The same thing is happening now. “Demand continues to surge and freight rates are accelerating, so driver pay is as well—and at a rapid pace,” Shaver said. “Driver wages, which have traditionally lagged behind inflation and outlined a gap between for-hire and private fleets, are actually accelerating in response to rising freight rates as increased demand has outstripped capacity in most markets and turnover is on the rise.”

Adopting tactics such as salary pay, hourly pay, hybrid mileage, and dedicated lanes can also woo or keep drivers. Wage hikes are a good start, but Shaver said driver engagement must accompany those increases. These include video messages, surveys, and overall transparency from the top of the organization. Allowing drivers to grow and obtain leadership roles can also ensure drivers make trucking a career. Driver wellness programs can also mitigate driver wear and tear and keep those good drivers on the road longer.

“Some of the best fleets that perform at retention are using all of these tools,” Shaver said.

And these efforts must continue far beyond the recruitment phase. “One of the biggest gaps that we see with fleets is that they have amazing programs, they might market them to applicants to attract, but they don't continue to sell the job or the importance of that driver throughout their tenure as they stay with you,” she said.

Outreach to women, veterans, and the growing Latin community are other solid strategies, she said.

Fleet advice

Chris Polenz, vice president of recruiting at Werner Enterprises, said maintaining the right equipment can go a long way in keeping the right drivers. A younger fleet can retain drivers, he said.

Werner’s fleet age is currently two years, slightly up from the 1.8-year average. Another side effect of COVID-19 has been that new truckers have been harder to obtain, Polenz said.

Lowering the age of trailers from more than seven years down to about four has also helped Werner, Polenz said.

“We focus on the million-mile driver and making sure that their equipment is backed, and they can custom order those trucks the way they want them,” he said.

Part of this is ensuring the fleet has the truck they want.

“They're certainly brand loyal,” Polenz explained. “And everybody's got an uncle who would rather push a Chevy than drive a Ford. It’s the same thing with the [truck] OEMs out there. So you're going to have Freightliner, Kenworth, International-type of drivers and you're going to want to do everything you can to put them in the right equipment.”

Spec’ing the right technology can also help, such as geofencing of customer locations, and unloaded and loaded sensors, to help reduce processing time and make the time at loading docks less stressful.

Fleet managers and executives should also frequently perform terminal tours to make sure they are looking good and implement the latest technology.

Polenz agreed pay is still extremely important. He said pay packages are up as much as $20,000 over the last three to five years.

“Universally, the major carriers out there are paying their drivers,” he said.

The key for retention is in using data and analytics software to “understand when the right time to pay them” is.

“There are other companies out there that might advertise what a 10-year driver makes, maximizing every incentive bonus under the sun, but that's not going to get you long-term drivers,” Polenz said.

He said that may get a driver in the door, but they could get easily discouraged in a month and leave.

“So I tell our recruiters to be honest with the pay; we're proud of the pay, and it's going to be real,” he concluded.

About the Author

John Hitch | Editor

John Hitch, based out of Cleveland, Ohio, is the editor of Fleet Maintenance, a B2B magazine that addresses the service needs for all commercial vehicle makes and models (Classes 1-8), ranging from shop management strategies to the latest tools to enhance uptime.

He previously wrote about equipment and fleet operations and management for FleetOwner, and prior to that, manufacturing and advanced technology for IndustryWeek and New Equipment Digest. He is an award-winning journalist and former sonar technician aboard a nuclear-powered submarine.

For tips, questions or comments, email [email protected].

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of FleetOwner, create an account today!

Sponsored Recommendations

Report: The 2024 State of Heavy-Duty Repair

From capitalizing on the latest revenue trends to implementing strategic financial planning—this report serves as a roadmap for navigating the challenges and opportunities of ...

Fleet Industry Benchmarks: How does your fleet stack up?

Discover how your fleet compares to industry benchmarks and gain insights from a 2024 Benchmarking Report on maintenance spend, turnaround time, and more. Join us to identify ...

Build a Tolling Program to Manage Toll Fees and Risks

Fleets looking to effectively manage their operational costs should consider their tolling costs. Download the PrePass whitepaper, “Build a Tolling Program to Manage Toll Fees...

Reducing CSA Violations & Increasing Safety With Advanced Trailer Telematics

Keep the roads safer with advanced trailer telematics. In this whitepaper, see how you can gain insights that lead to increased safety and reduced roadside incidents—keeping drivers...