Light Trucks as Life Savers?

June 25, 2001
A report compiled by economic professors at Rutgers University and published by the Cato Institute, says that growing light truck usage by both consumer and commercial users may actually be reducing the number of highway fatalities every year – the exact opposite of claims made by both government and insurance groups. The study by Douglas Coate and James VanderHoff entitled "The Truth about Light

A report compiled by economic professors at Rutgers University and published by the Cato Institute, says that growing light truck usage by both consumer and commercial users may actually be reducing the number of highway fatalities every year – the exact opposite of claims made by both government and insurance groups.

The study by Douglas Coate and James VanderHoff entitled "The Truth about Light Trucks" says that over the last two decades, as the numbers of light trucks have doubled on America’s roads, the number of traffic fatalities has actually dropped by 30%. That includes a decrease in fatalities per capita, per licensed driver, and per registered vehicles, say Coate and VanderHoff.

The authors add that the U.S. has also witnessed a 50% decline accident fatalities per vehicle mile traveled – a statistic that suggests “large, stiff-framed light trucks may be lowering traffic fatalities instead of increasing them.”

The report says that though stiffer drunk driver penalties, improved overall automotive technology, and the re-introduction of 55 mph speed limits have contributed to lower numbers of highway fatalities, the intrinsic safety benefits of light trucks have been overlooked.

The study suggests that the stiffer frames and greater weights of light trucks – both pickups and SUVs – are more protective of passengers in collisions that do not involve other vehicles. The professors also found that those design benefits offset fatalities associated with multiple-vehicle accidents, meaning more lives overall are saved, as opposed to accidents involving cars alone.

According to the report’s calculations, light trucks actually help lower single-vehicle fatalities by 7.5%, according to accident data gathered between 1994 and 1997, while lowering the fatality rate in multiple vehicle crashes by 2%. Those numbers translate into 2,000 lives saved over that three-year period because of the wider use of light trucks.

About the Author

Sean Kilcarr | Editor in Chief

Sean previously reported and commented on trends affecting the many different strata of the trucking industry. Also be sure to visit Sean's blog Trucks at Work where he offers analysis on a variety of different topics inside the trucking industry.

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of FleetOwner, create an account today!

Sponsored Recommendations

Seasonal Strategies for Maintaining a Safe & Efficient Fleet Year-Round

Prepare your fleet for every season! From winterizing vehicles to summer heat safety, our eBook covers essential strategies for year-round fleet safety. Download now to reduce...

Streamline Compliance, Ensure Safety and Maximize Driver's Time

Truck weight isn’t the first thing that comes to mind when considering operational efficiency, hours-of-service regulations, and safety ratings, but it can affect all three.

Improve Safety and Reduce Risk with Data from Route Scores

Route Scores help fleets navigate the risk factors they encounter in the lanes they travel, helping to keep costs down.

Celebrating Your Drivers Can Prove to be Rewarding For Your Business

Learn how to jumpstart your driver retention efforts by celebrating your drivers with a thoughtful, uniform-led benefits program by Red Kap®. Uniforms that offer greater comfort...