Fontana: How fleet managers can reduce litigation risks and improve truck safety

Fleets face growing legal risks tied to staged crashes, litigation tactics, and changing standards of care.

Key takeaways

  • Nuclear verdicts are increasing pressure on fleets to strengthen litigation risk management.
  • ADAS technology can support safer operations but does not replace trained, attentive drivers.
  • Ongoing driver coaching, telematics monitoring, and leadership engagement are key parts of fleet safety.

It seems like every other day we are hearing about some multimillion-dollar verdicts against trucking companies. According to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s Institute for Legal Reform Study, in 2023 the median verdict was $760,000, and that number had jumped to $3 million in the first half of this year.

At the American Trucking Associations (ATA) Management Conference & Exhibition (MCE), the Institute for Legal Reform cited six factors that are causing this jump.

  • Interconnected fraud networks
  • Reptile tactics and anchoring
  • Flawed statutes and evidentiary rules
  • New lawsuit targets
  • Uncertain standards of care
  • Third-party litigation funding

Many of these factors are outside the control of fleets; however, fleet managers need to be vigilant and look for patterns to spot things such as staged accidents, and they need to work with authorities to shut down the perpetrators of this type of fraud. Additionally, fleet managers should work with their legislators to review legislation and enact regulations that will prevent predatory litigation.

In addition, fleet managers need to review vehicle specs to evaluate safety-related technologies that make sense for their operations. There are a host of advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) available, including collision warning, lane departure/lane keeping, blind spot warning, adaptive cruise control, and more. Spec’ing these types of options can make the truck safer, but it is important to remember that they do not take the place of a well-trained driver.

Driver safety training needs to be an ongoing effort, not just something that happens during onboarding. The use of cell phones and other distractions that contribute to distracted driving must be outined and reinforced in safe driving policies. Hard braking, fast starts, incidents of following too closely, speeding, etc., should be tracked via telematics devices and then used to coach drivers in order to improve their driving habits.

Drivers who achieve certain safety milestones should be publicly recognized for their achievements, and fleet leadership needs to be at the forefront of speaking about the importance of safety throughout the organization. By their actions, leadership needs to show that they are doing more than just giving lip service to safety.

It is going to take a coordinated effort to rein in nuclear verdicts, but fleet managers and drivers can do their part to make sure their vehicles are spec’d and driven with safety in mind.

About the Author

Gino Fontana

Gino Fontana

Chief operating officer and executive vice president at Transervice Logistics Inc.

Gino Fontana, CTP, is COO and EVP at Transervice Logistics Inc. His operational expertise emphasizes cost savings, process efficiency and improvement, superior quality, and people management skills. He has more than 35 years of experience in the transportation and logistics industry with both operational and sales experience.

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates

Voice Your Opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of FleetOwner, create an account today!